The 15 Worst Quarterbacks in NFL History, Ranked | Fanbuzz

Quarterback is without doubt one of the most troublesome positions to play in skilled sports activities. The Nationwide Soccer League is infamous for chewing up and spitting out lower-tier quarterbacks sooner than they’ll open the playbook (Sorry, Brogan Roback). It’s a demanding place that requires relentless particular person preparation as a way to be the sector basic on recreation day.

No quarterback makes it to the NFL by mistake. You may name it dangerous teaching or unlucky circumstances enjoying for horrible groups, however in some instances, issues simply go awry. Regardless if they’d a rocket arm, have been school soccer standouts or have been billed as dual-threat game-changers, some guys can’t hack it within the execs.

See more: Worst quarterbacks of all time

Traditionally, there are extra dangerous quarterbacks than nice ones to play professionally, however right here is our record of the 15 worst quarterbacks in NFL historical past. Don’t count on many playoff stars or sixth-round picks like former New England Patriots and three-time MVP Bucs’ Tom Brady. Most of those guys are first-round busts. They’ll blame their head coach all they need, however dangerous quarterback play is simply dangerous quarterback play.

Dishonorable mentions: Tim Sofa (Cleveland Browns, Inexperienced Bay Packers, Jacksonville Jaguars), John Reaves (Philadelphia Eagles, Cincinnati Bengals, Minnesota Vikings, Houston Oilers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers), Dave Brown (New York Giants, Arizona Cardinals), Todd Blackledge (Kansas Metropolis Chiefs, Pittsburgh Steelers), Kyle Boller (Baltimore Ravens, St. Louis Rams, Oakland Raiders).

The 15 Worst Quarterbacks in NFL Historical past

15. Jack Thompson

Jack Thompson
AP Picture/Ed Reinke

Groups: Cincinnati Bengals, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

File: 4-17

TD to INT Ratio: 33-45

The “Throwin’ Samoan” lands first on this record as one of many greatest draft busts at quarterback of all-time. Chosen third total within the first spherical of the 1979 NFL Draft (the identical draft that produced Phil Simms and Joe Montana), Thompson’s school profession was much more prolific than his skilled one. At Washington State, he set quite a few Pac-10 data and completed as school soccer’s all-time chief in passing yards on the time.


Within the NFL, he by no means gained greater than two video games in a season as a starter and had a professional soccer profession completion share of 53.1. Thompson was out of soccer after six seasons.

14. Jack Trudeau

Jack Trudeau
Jonathan Daniel/Allsport/Getty Pictures

Groups: Indianapolis Colts, New York Jets, Carolina Panthers

File: 19-30

TD to INT Ratio: 42-69

One of many longest-tenured NFL quarterbacks on this record, Trudeau performed 10 seasons within the NFL. In school enjoying for Illinois, he set the NCAA report for many consecutive go makes an attempt with out an interception (215). Within the NFL, he threw an interception as soon as each 23 throws. Trudeau’s most well-known fail was his rookie season, when he began 11 video games for Indianapolis and managed to lose all 11 of them.

To his credit score, he did handle to place collectively a good season in 1989, successful seven video games and having his solely season with extra touchdowns than interceptions. He’s a mid-level bust being a second-round draft choose, however Trudeau is the final word “eh, he’s simply Jack” sort of participant.

13. Mike Phipps

Mike Phipps
Wikimedia Commons

Groups: Cleveland Browns, Chicago Bears

File: 38-31-2

TD to INT Ratio: 55-108

Phipps is simply quarterback on this record with a successful report, however the third total choose in 1970 is right here for one purpose: Return On Funding. Phipps was initially drafted by the Miami Dolphins, who then traded him to the Cleveland Browns. And who did the Browns hand over? Future Corridor of Fame large receiver Paul Warfield, who went on to be a member of two Tremendous Bowl groups in Miami.

See also  Scoreboards – Top 10 Baseball Tragedies of All Time


Phipps did quarterback two NFL groups that had mixed data of 19-4, however while you throw almost twice as many interceptions as touchdowns, and full lower than half your profession passes, your groups are successful despite you…

12. Joey Harrington

Joey Harrington Lions
Picture By Eliot J. Schechter/Getty Pictures

Groups: Detroit Lions, Miami Dolphins, Atlanta Falcons, New Orleans Saints

File: 26-50

TD to INT Ratio: 79-85

One of many greatest “what if” tales on this countdown is the Oregon Geese product, Joey Harrington. One of many Geese most prolific offensive gamers of all-time, Harrington was buried on a poorly managed and coached Detroit Lions staff for the primary 4 seasons of his profession. Nonetheless, while you’re chosen third total, you’ve gotten some duty to hold the franchise that chosen you.

Harrington led the NFL in 2005 with 22 interceptions, and solely as soon as completed a season with extra touchdowns than picks. After his Lions profession fizzled out, he turned a journeyman backup for 3 totally different franchises earlier than leaving soccer for good in 2009.

11. Rick Norton

Rick Norton Dolphins
Picture by Concentrate on Sport/Getty Pictures

Groups: Miami Dolphins, Inexperienced Bay Packers

File: 1-10

TD to INT Ratio: 7-30

A member of the Kentucky Wildcats Corridor of Fame, Norton was drafted 2nd total within the 1966 AFL Draft to play for the Miami Dolphins. Whereas the passing recreation wasn’t as developed as it’s immediately, Norton helped set the usual for precisely what to not do as a quarterback. He as soon as went 7-of-26 for 43 yards and 5 interceptions in a 32-7 loss to the Houston Oilers.


The one recreation he appeared in for the Inexperienced Bay Packers was really the very best rated recreation of his profession, finishing 3-of-5 passes for 64 years and a landing. I assume you would possibly as effectively exit with a bang?

10. Andrew Walter

Andrew Walter Raiders
Picture by MediaNews Group/Bay Space Information by way of Getty Pictures

Groups: Oakland Raiders

File: 2-7

TD to INT Ratio: 3-16

Have you learnt the tune “Lose Your self” by Eminem? The one which begins:

Should you had one shot or one alternative To grab the whole lot you ever wished In a single second Would you seize it, or simply let it slip?

Properly, Andrew Walter let it slip. The previous highschool All-American and All-Pac 10 quarterback at Arizona State began eight video games as a rookie in 2006. He threw 13 interceptions and fumbled the ball 13 instances whereas main his staff to a 2-6 report. Walter was out of soccer after three seasons. The subsequent yr, the Raiders drafted JaMarcus Russell, who you’ll be assembly later on this record…

9. David Klingler

David Klingler Bengals
Picture by Rick Stewart/Getty Pictures

Groups: Cincinatti Bengals, Oakland Raiders

File: 4-20

TD to INT Ratio: 16-22


Considered one of school soccer’s most embellished passers, the College of Houston product as soon as threw 11 touchdowns in a recreation, set the report for many yards in a recreation (716), and set the single-season report for landing passes by throwing 54 in solely 11 video games.

Sadly, school success didn’t translate for Klingler, who was the sixth total choose in 1992. He performed on 4 horrible Bengals groups, then was despatched to the place quarterbacks go to die in Oakland. An elbow surgical procedure in 1994 in the end restricted what he may do, and he was out of soccer by 1998.

See also  Life After Baseball, Part 1 | FanGraphs Baseball

8. Chris Weinke

Chris Weinke
AP Picture/Chris O’Meara

RELATED: The NFL Failed Charlie Ward, And The League Missed a Legend

Groups: Carolina Panthers, San Francisco 49ers

File: 2-18

TD to INT Ratio: 15-26

The oldest Heisman Trophy winner in historical past — he was 28 successful it at Florida State — Weinke really began his skilled profession enjoying baseball for the Toronto Blue Jays, making it as much as the Triple-A degree earlier than leaping again to soccer. Nevertheless, none of that success translated to the NFL for the Seminoles’ nice.

Weinke gained his first begin with the Carolina Panthers as a rookie, then managed to lose 17 consecutive video games as a starter, together with a niche between begins that spanned from 2002 to 2006. Typically, knowledge and age simply doesn’t enable you to out.


7. Frank Tripucka

Frank Tripucka
Picture By Duane Howell/The Denver Publish by way of Getty Pictures

Groups: Detroit Lions, Chicago Cardinals, Dallas Texans, Denver Broncos

File: 17-34-1

TD to INT Ratio: 69-124

The ninth total choose in 1949 has one of many strangest careers in skilled soccer. After throwing 18 touchdowns and 39 interceptions in 4 seasons with three groups, Tripucka took his expertise to Canada and performed within the CFL for eight years. Then in 1960, he returned to hitch the Denver Broncos within the growth American Soccer League. That season, he led the league in completions, makes an attempt, yards and threw a Broncos franchise report 34 interceptions (the third most in a season in league historical past).

He was additionally someway named the Professional Bowl in 1962 regardless of a 6-7 report and throwing 25 extra interceptions. Stranger nonetheless, his No. 18 jersey was retired in Denver, then un-retired so Peyton Manning may put on it, then it was retired once more.

6. Matt Leinart

Matt Leinart Cardinals
Picture by MediaNews Group/San Mateo County Occasions by way of Getty Pictures

Groups: Arizona Cardinals, Houston Texans, Oakland Raiders

File: 8-10

TD to INT Ratio: 15-21

Considered one of school soccer’s best passers was the golden boy from California, Matt Leinart. A highly-touted recruit from highschool powerhouse Mater Dei, Leinart is extra well-known for his school achievements at USC and remembered because the glass man within the NFL.

Three season-ending accidents ended the tenth total choose’s yr in an eight-start window, and the southpaw was in the end was out of soccer by 2012. To make issues worse, Leinart was introduced in for exercises with the Buffalo Payments in 2013. He was crushed out for the job as Buffalo’s fourth-string quarterback by Thad Lewis. At the very least he held out for that six-year, $51 million contract as a rookie, proper?

5. Heath Shuler

Heath Shuler Washington
Doug Pensinger/ALLSPORT/Getty Pictures

Groups: Washington Redskins, New Orleans Saints

File: 8-14

TD to INT Ratio: 15-33

The 1993 SEC Participant of the Yr popping out of Tennessee, Shuler was heralded as Washington’s quarterback of the long run once they chosen him third total in 1994 and signed him to a seven-year contract. Properly, issues didn’t go so effectively for Shuler, as he began his profession with a 1-7 report as a rookie and was ultimately changed by seventh-round choose Gus Frerotte after two horrible seasons.

A nagging foot damage pressured Shuler out of soccer after a two-touchdown and 14-interception season enjoying for the Saints. Soccer wasn’t his calling, however Shuler went on to function a member of the Home of Representatives for North Carolina’s 11 District.

4. Kim McQuilken

Kim McQuilken

Groups: Atlanta Falcons, Washington Redskins

See also  A Sports Fans Bucket List: The Best Sporting Events You Can Attend – UrbanMatter

File: 2-5

TD to INT Ratio: 4-29

McQuilken wasn’t a protracted tenured quarterback by any means, however what he completed throughout 26 video games and 7 begins is downright forgetful. The third-round choose from Lehigh College has a profession 17.9 passer ranking and one of many worst touchdown-to-interception ratios in league historical past.

He accomplished 39.7 % of his passes and threw one choose for each NINE passes he let fly. His NFL profession someway spanned seven seasons earlier than he retired and tried his luck with the Washington Federals in america Soccer League. He threw seven touchdowns and 14 interceptions throughout their 4-14 season in 1983.

3. Akili Smith

Akili Smith Bengals
Scott Halleran/Allsport/Getty Pictures

Groups: Cincinatti Bengals

File: 3-14

TD to INT Ratio: 5-13

The third total choose in 1999 by no means had the psychological fortitude to maintain tempo along with his bodily expertise. Smith scored a 16 out of fifty on the NFL-administered Wonderlic Take a look at — a rating of 20 is taken into account an individual of common intelligence — and also you want no less than a ten to be thought of literate.

Smith’s skilled soccer profession lasted 4 seasons within the NFL earlier than he tried his hand with the Frankfurt Galaxy of NFL Europe, and later had stints with a number of groups within the Canadian Soccer League. One of many greatest busts in NFL historical past in all probability ought to have caught with skilled baseball.

2. JaMarcus Russell

Jamarcus Russell Throws Ball For Raiders
Picture by Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Pictures

Groups: Oakland Raiders

File: 7-18

TD to INT Ratio: 18-23

Contemplating the previous LSU Tigers quarterback held out for a $61 million contract with $32 million assured, that is simply the worst quarterback to ever receives a commission. Russell threw 23 profession interceptions and fumbled 25 instances over his three skilled seasons. Often exhibiting as much as coaching camps out of form and chubby, it was reported that Russell as soon as got here to Raiders camp north of 300 kilos. The primary total choose in 2007 was bounced from the league and tried just a few comebacks, none of which resulted in Russell getting a job within the NFL once more.

1. Ryan Leaf

Ryan Leaf at NFL Draft
Picture by Concentrate on Sport/Getty Pictures

Groups: San Diego Chargers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Dallas Cowboys, Seattle Seahawks

File: 4-17

TD to INT Ratio: 14-36

A star at Washington State College, Ryan Leaf ranks as the largest draft bust in NFL historical past. That’s amplified previous our pal JaMarcus Russell, as a result of many individuals thought it was a toss-up between taking both Leaf or Peyton Manning at No. 1 within the 1998 NFL Draft. Leaf performed three horrible seasons for the San Diego Chargers, often received into verbal altercations with members of the media and training employees and was out of soccer due to it. Solely as soon as in his profession did he have a passer ranking above 100, and he accomplished an abysmal 48.8 % of his passes.

While you’re as extremely touted and bodily gifted as Leaf, and you are taking your profession in that type of course? You’re the worst quarterback in NFL historical past.

This text was initially revealed October 15, 2018, however we’re at all times on the lookout for new horrible quarterbacks so as to add so as to add to this record.

MORE: Rating the SEC’s 15 Finest Quarterbacks of All-Time

Associated Movies

function pinIt()
var e = document.createElement(‘script’);

Similar Articles

Most Popular